• Updated 2023-07-12: Hello, Guest! Welcome back, and be sure to check out this follow-up post about our outage a week or so ago.

Recommended SSD IDE Solutions for G3 iBooks?

macuserman

Well-known member
Pretty much the title, anyone have a solution for an SSD to IDE 2.5" solution in a G3 iBook? I'm specifically looking for a late model drive so if there is any issues with the clamshell models etc that shouldn't impact me. 14" G3 700-900Mhz machine is the target here. There are several options out there, but wanted to save myself the buy and try churn if someone has already got something that they know works.

Thanks!
 

Phipli

Well-known member
If it isn't a daily driver, 12 hours / day machine, I've had excellent luck with these in my Pismos and 1400. This specific style has a laptop style IDE connector and full size SD Card. Note that they run faster than my stock Pismo drives by quite a way!

 

macuserman

Well-known member
If it isn't a daily driver, 12 hours / day machine, I've had excellent luck with these in my Pismos and 1400. This specific style has a laptop style IDE connector and full size SD Card. Note that they run faster than my stock Pismo drives by quite a way!

Nice! It's for my son to run educational software on it, so it will get a fair bit of use although not 12hours a day or anything like that. Still trying to source the right machine but wanted to know what ssd options are out there. Was pretty set on the high end G3 iBooks but the GPU issues are killing my options there. Almost no choice of functional machine for sale, just parts units on fleabay. I may have to reconsider, I had him setup with a G3 tower but it takes up to much space for how often he uses it, so trying to find a laptop equivalent, and avoiding G4 units for reasons...
 

Phipli

Well-known member
Nice! It's for my son to run educational software on it, so it will get a fair bit of use although not 12hours a day or anything like that. Still trying to source the right machine but wanted to know what ssd options are out there. Was pretty set on the high end G3 iBooks but the GPU issues are killing my options there. Almost no choice of functional machine for sale, just parts units on fleabay. I may have to reconsider, I had him setup with a G3 tower but it takes up to much space for how often he uses it, so trying to find a laptop equivalent, and avoiding G4 units for reasons...
Have you considered a Mac Mini, or is it all G4s, not just laptops? You can run OS 9 on the 1.25 and 1.42 (I believe there are issues on the 1.5) with a patched version of OS 9.
 

Skate323k137

Well-known member
I'm currently using an mSATA in my Pismo with an adapter. It's quite nice. If you want info on it let me know but I found it on this same forum.
 

macuserman

Well-known member
Have you considered a Mac Mini, or is it all G4s, not just laptops? You can run OS 9 on the 1.25 and 1.42 (I believe there are issues on the 1.5) with a patched version of OS 9.
It needs to be easily put away so has to be a laptop. Also really only looking for native OS9 support I could get a TI book I do love them, I have had several over the years but I wanted something a bit tougher since it's my kid who will be using it and I don't want him to have to baby it as much. I also just prefer a G3 if possible due to personal taste. Wonder if herd could redo the GPU on a iBook G3 and have it last vs all the shimming and other nonsense people try.

I'm currently using an mSATA in my Pismo with an adapter. It's quite nice. If you want info on it let me know but I found it on this same forum.
OK I can probably search that, I do like Pismo machines a lot and they are pretty tough, I was looking for something a little bit faster though.
 

Skate323k137

Well-known member
OK I can probably search that, I do like Pismo machines a lot and they are pretty tough, I was looking for something a little bit faster though.
If a (slightly?) newer machine uses the same HDD interface, it should be OK.

When using an adapter to IDE/PATA, I like using mSATA enclosures when possible over SD card for endurance sake, and the speed is good.
 

joshc

Well-known member
I'm currently using an mSATA in my Pismo with an adapter. It's quite nice. If you want info on it let me know but I found it on this same forum.
Which mSATA adapter and which mSATA SSD do you tend to use? Im looking for a solution for my Pismo.
 

ArmorAlley

Well-known member
Pretty much the title, anyone have a solution for an SSD to IDE 2.5" solution in a G3 iBook?
I'm using an mSATA card in an IDE-mSATA adapter in my Mac Mini G4 and it benchmarks substantially faster than my 32GB IDE SSD, a CF card in an adapter or an SD card in an adapter.
Both mSATA card and adapter are generic cards from AliExpress.
 

joshc

Well-known member
I'm using an mSATA card in an IDE-mSATA adapter in my Mac Mini G4 and it benchmarks substantially faster than my 32GB IDE SSD, a CF card in an adapter or an SD card in an adapter.
Both mSATA card and adapter are generic cards from AliExpress.
I guess on this basis any of the ones on eBay should work too.
 

Daniël

Well-known member
I wouldn't consider mSATA in 2022. The drives have gotten scarce, whatever's left is mostly low grade junk. M.2 superseded mSATA, as it supports both NVMe (PCIe bus) and SATA. Cheap 128GB OEM drives from slightly better quality manufacturers than most available mSATA manufacturers can be had cheap, but you do need to specifically look for SATA drives. Cheap M.2 SATA NGFF to 2.5" IDE adapters are available on AliExpress and such, most people seem to have good luck with them (They use the JM20330 chipset, similar to some other full SATA and mSATA adapters).
 
Last edited:

Skate323k137

Well-known member
Which mSATA adapter and which mSATA SSD do you tend to use? Im looking for a solution for my Pismo.
Drive

Transcend 128GB SATA III 6GB/S MSA230S mSATA SSD 230S Solid State Drive TS128GMSA230S https://a.co/d/1GRnQKb

Adapter

Ableconn IIDE-MSAT mSATA SSD to 2.5-Inch IDE Adapter Converter with Aluminum Frame Bracket - Latch and Retain mSATA SSD as 9.5mm 2.5" IDE SSD Drive https://a.co/d/124RjML

It's been rock solid, funny that the adapter costs more than the drive now though.
 

ArmorAlley

Well-known member
I wouldn't consider mSATA in 2022. The drives have gotten scarce, whatever's left is mostly low grade junk. M.2 superseded mSATA, as it supports both NVMe (PCIe bus) and SATA. Cheap 128GB OEM drives from slightly better quality manufacturers than most available mSATA manufacturers can be had cheap, but you do need to specifically look for SATA drives. Cheap M.2 SATA NGFF to 2.5" IDE adapters are available on AliExpress and such, most people seem to have good luck with them (They use the JM20330 chipset, similar to some other full SATA and mSATA adapters).
This is good to know and would explain the cheap prices.
Back up regularly & often is my take-away here.
 

Skate323k137

Well-known member
M.2 would be interesting, if I ever run into issues in the Pismo or need to upgrade another similar system I'll give it a shot.

I normally try to use actual SSDs over CF or SD because of concern for longevity of multiple writes, but I can't scientifically back that up so don't take it as gospel (Do mSATA SSD's usually do wear leveling?)
 

davidg5678

Well-known member
I wouldn't consider mSATA in 2022. The drives have gotten scarce, whatever's left is mostly low grade junk. M.2 superseded mSATA, as it supports both NVMe (PCIe bus) and SATA. Cheap 128GB OEM drives from slightly better quality manufacturers than most available mSATA manufacturers can be had cheap, but you do need to specifically look for SATA drives. Cheap M.2 SATA NGFF to 2.5" IDE adapters are available on AliExpress and such, most people seem to have good luck with them (They use the JM20330 chipset, similar to some other full SATA and mSATA adapters).
Interesting! I never realized m.2 sata and mSATA we're different technologies. I just checked the m.2 sata prices, and they seem pretty reasonable, so I'll have to give it a try when I need a new IDE SSD.
 

joshc

Well-known member
Good point, M.2 would make more sense these days. I'll have a look to see what the options are.
 

Daniël

Well-known member
Interesting! I never realized m.2 sata and mSATA we're different technologies. I just checked the m.2 sata prices, and they seem pretty reasonable, so I'll have to give it a try when I need a new IDE SSD.
mSATA preceded M.2 by a few years. M.2 basically replaced it and mini-PCIe in one fell swoop.

Good point, M.2 would make more sense these days. I'll have a look to see what the options are.
You can sometimes find sellers with lots of multiple drives, pulled from old laptops that were upgraded. I bought ten 128GB drives, seemingly a common capacity for budget laptops, for 7,50 euros each. With the adapter, it's not too bad for maxing out the storage on the earlier IDE PPC Macs that have the 128GB addressing limit.
 
Top