• Hello MLAers! We've re-enabled auto-approval for accounts. If you are still waiting on account approval, please check this thread for more information.

Quad G5

I'm that rarity, a G5 fan (yes, yes, I know, Intel is — y ... a ... w ... n — way faster/ newer/ shinier/ identikitier). For the past couple of years I've been looking for the prices of the quad G5 to come down to reasonable levels, as well as for something local so as to avoid the dreaded bashed case from shipment and the brutal shipping charges themselves.

I found one locally over the weekend and picked it up today. Nice shape, very pleased to get it. This is going to be put to work daily at the office, replacing a dual 2.0 G5 for running older ppc office software (CS2 etc.). Very little web work is required, beyond static pages and email. I think a quad G5 will cope nicely.

What maintenance do quad owners recommend at this stage, beyond a fresh system and vacuuming out the dust bunnies? Is it even possible for me to do my customary G5 heatsink compound renewal routine on this thing? Never had anything liquid-cooled before.

 
Check around the top case of the power supply, under the LCS - this is the first place to look for any leaking coolant. It might just look like some staining on the metal casing, raised felt lining or a crusty build-up. Chances are for longevity you will one day want to rebuild the LCS with new coolant line, coolant, and O-ring seals.

I was given a Quad G5 and love it, but reckon it's due for a rebuild, not for leaking but I suspect some of the coolant has dried up/gunked up inside, or the pump is dying. It reports a logic board error when I first power it up (assuming it hasn't been used for a couple of weeks), but after ~ 20 minutes and a reboot it reports all is well. I'm assuming that's due to the coolant being more effectively pumped through during this initial "warm-up" phase, for various reasons as noted.

Still, an awesome machine which performs well to this day, try to find as many late PPC apps as you can for it :)

 
I've never personally seen problems involving leaks on the second generation G5's LCU. By then I suppose the problems had been sorted out.

One thing that might still be a problem is the use of ROHS solder and the heat given off by the memory controller until it finally detaches and renders the board useless. Again, I've never used a second gen so I can't say first hand but it always seems when a G5 diesn't drown, it dies from BGA contact failure.

 
@beachycove Hey man, show no fear about your love for the G5 my friend. I've got a Dual 1.8 Ghz G5 that I used for the longest time before retiring it (stashing it in my collection) from service because I needed an Intel Mac for my desktop. It's got 8 GB RAM, 1TB HDD, Bluetooth and Airport Extreme (had to install those two myself when I found it). The only complaint that I had was the original SuperDrive stuck every once in a while, but I got that fixed up too. :lol: I can't tell you how may times my friends wanted me to get rid of that thing for a modern computer, but I could never (and still can't) part with it. Hauled me through so many years lol. Enjoy your G5 and keep showing your support!

 
You can do almost everything with a G5! It is still a really good computer.

You know, I still use my powerbook G4 quite often as it is my only laptop. Here is my personal experience :

- Tiger is faster/lighter than Leopard on the G4 (don't know if it's the case on the G5 though)

- Web browsing is really good with Ten4Fox. Even safari 4 works quite fast under Tiger.

- If you want to watch your DivX movies, just install Perian and watch them in QuickTime 7.

- If you like watching youtube videos at full speed, just try MacTubes and set the videos to be displayed in MP4 / SD format. It is really fast on the G4 even in full screen mode. Also, there is no advert with MactTubes ;)

- I have done a lot of video editing on the G4 and unless you really need HD, your G5 will be a fantastic editing station with the old Final Cut.

I don't know exactly what you plan to do with the G5 but no doubt it can be a really good daily driver!

 
Years and years ago, when dinosaurs roamed the earth, when a 68020 was considered blisteringly fast, and when I was about to buy my first computer (a PC-XT clone from Epson, since as a postgrad student I could not afford a Mac), I went to the library and read up on the theory and practice of buying a personal computer. This was in the days when a computer was a luxury rather than a commodity, and so in a sense before we quite knew what they were. Accordingly, there used to be books on the subject, with chapter titles like, "What is a Computer?" or "What Can You Do with a Computer?"

I had worked with text on a mainframe previously (using Scribe, which was a little like TeX), so it was not all entirely novel, but having a computer of my own did really represent a shift in how I lived and worked. I found a piece of sage advice in the book I picked up, and I think it has served me well over the years: you don't really use a computer, what you really use is software. So think first of what software you want to run, since the computer you choose should be chosen with a view to what you want/need software to do. I have kept that piece of wisdom in my head all these years.

For instance, my MacBook Pro (latest issue -- I do have to use up to date tools also) will not run a good deal of the software I have found, purchased, invested time on learning, and so on, and that I would still like to run, dammit! Much of my most useful software is PPC-based. Some things the MBP really ought to run it will run at best in patchy fashion (e.g., there are small bits and pieces of older "Universal binary" versions of FileMaker (v. 9) that will not run without Rosetta). So if I want to use some of my perfectly-good software, and avoid the most egregious assaults of the kind of "progress" that just leaves me doing the same things, at much the same pace, but much more expensively, I need tools to run it on.

Similarly, if I want to run decent open-source software, or the latest from Microsoft, I can forget about a PPC machine. So I have, for instance, a cheap AMD-based ThinkPad running Ubuntu, and a MBP with Mountain Lion. I need those for certain things. But for PPC software, you cannot beat a G5, and a high-end G5 will run PPC software with aplomb. So, as long as the PPC software meets my needs, so will a G5.

Eventually, inevitably, my PPC software will cease to be quite so useful, and then I'll have to move on, but happily, I have some way to go still before that happens. I think eventually that I will likely move to some version of Linux, as I have been experimenting with it, and like what I see (in some major ways it reminds me of what it was like to use a Mac in the mid-90s, bucking the trend and all that), but that is for another day.

For people who work in software development, of course, or who are serious about games, or who want to watch internet video 24/7, the day to switch came some time ago. Hence the loathing for the G5 from certain quarters. Me? I just need to read and produce text, exchange it with peers, record/edit/publish basic audio (human speech), run a database, and network with perfectly serviceable printers etc. from days of yore that it would be madness to throw out, or to throw out just yet. For this sort of thing, a G5 suits me to a T, better than the newer stuff in fact.

Having a quad to play with now is icing on the cake.

 
Back
Top