Author |
Topic |
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 15 Dec 2002 : 07:12:22
Testing some RAM obtained from Cinemo, reconnected the HD to find it didn't work (on a IIfx you have to remove the platform carrying the drives to get at the RAM). This trusty Apple-branded 160MB Seagate drive has worked flawlessly since I've had the computer (c. 1990). I may have plugged the ribbon cable into the MB backwards. Could this have fried the drive?Reconnecting properly, I get a blank screen; no pointer, no question mark, just a lit screen. If I disconnect the drive, the IIfx will boot from a floppy, but not if the drive is connected. The drive does not spin up or make any sound whatsoever. Neither does the computer. Darn! Sometimes the biggest danger to one's computer is oneself! Any advice? /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven Edited by - mrlynn on 15 Dec 2002 07:29:38 |
geekwurkz
Junior Member
USA
156 Posts |
Posted - 15 Dec 2002 : 09:08:49
It's possible, although the chances are rare. You might want to check that the drive wasn't damaged when you put it back (i.e. dents, noise when you *gently* tilt it, etc.) and that all the jumpers are still there.On my Packard Hell They didn't put anything on the board to show how the cables should be plugged in but it hasn't killed any of my HDDs. Nick
------------------------- DJ Corps "Bass is Good" 68k Liberations: 3 (PB 140, Centris 610, Classic) A-II Liberations: 1 (IIgs) In Progress: ?? (too many too count) |
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 15 Dec 2002 : 09:23:32
Well, moved the whole platform with the HD and the floppy drive on it, lifted it off and put it on a bed. So I don't think there were any shocks.The fact that the IIfx won't even show a flashing question mark with the drive connected leads me to think that there's some kind of electronics (not mechanical) problem. I guess I could try a different ribbon, in hopes that it's just a cable problem. . . . /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven Edited by - mrlynn on 15 Dec 2002 15:03:19 |
foetoid
Full Member
USA
554 Posts |
Posted - 15 Dec 2002 : 16:01:00
you didn't somehow manage to plug the power cable in wrong did you? I did that with a Zip drive in my 6400 and fried that puppy like crazy. Check that.________________ foetoid, that's (fee-toy-duh) http://www.foetoid.doesntexist.com |
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 15 Dec 2002 : 18:07:11
Power cable has a clip on one side, so goes in only one way. Would that everything was that idiot-proof./Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
foetoid
Full Member
USA
554 Posts |
Posted - 15 Dec 2002 : 19:01:43
i didn't know if something was broken... I've seen that one happen b4 to my friend.... he caught it b4 he turned it on tho.________________ foetoid, that's (fee-toy-duh) http://www.foetoid.doesntexist.com |
Kami
Junior Member
Canada
132 Posts |
Posted - 15 Dec 2002 : 22:09:08
This may sound crazy but I've done it to my fx...When you removed the SCSI cable from the drive did you by chance loosen the cable where it connects to the motherboard? Kami
|
Flash
Full Member
Australia
637 Posts |
Posted - 15 Dec 2002 : 22:45:51
Sounds more like SCSI voodoo may be the problem. Check your termination...etc68k ParaMedic |
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Dec 2002 : 05:59:47
This is a big ol' (physically, not virtually) internal drive and presumably is pre-set at SCSI 0 and auto-terminated (?). I disconnected everything connected to the external SCSI port, temporarily.Kami-- Did you solve the problem, or was your drive killed? I have been plugging and unplugging at the motherboard side, BTW. /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Dec 2002 : 06:52:58
Update: using the new ribbon cable didn't help. /Mr L The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 16 Dec 2002 : 07:38:53
quote:
Update: using the new ribbon cable didn't help.
Do you have anything to use to test the SCSI controller with at all? Any CD, HDD, scanner,Duo or another PB in SCSIDM could enable you to better isolate the problem.jt
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Dec 2002 : 08:46:03
I have an old LaCie 1G Q-Drive, which I have just connected and which boots the IIfx fine. So I assume this means the buss and controller are OK--right?(The LaCie has a fan that groans and moans--at least I hope it's the fan, and not the drive [I have another one whose drive died, in which I installed a 4.3G drive--use it for backup of my G3 data]--but the drive seems to work all right.) In fact, I switched to OS 7.6.1, which I had on the Q-Drive, and that works! With all the RAM (now 70MB--almost nine times as much as the old IIfx has ever seen!) it boots fast. No more need for RAMDoubler! But it looks like I'll need to find a replacement for the big ol' internal drive, maybe a one or two gig. Unless there's some way to resurrect it--it's a shame to have killed it by my own incompetence, after good service all these years. Is there any limit to the size of internal drive that the IIfx can support? /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 16 Dec 2002 : 11:44:41
quote:
I have an old LaCie 1G Q-Drive, which I have just connected and which boots the IIfx fine. So I assume this means the buss and controller are OK--right?But it looks like I'll need to find a replacement for the big ol' internal drive, maybe a one or two gig. Unless there's some way to resurrect it-- Is there any limit to the size of internal drive that the IIfx can support?
Ayup, that'd be my guess! Why not replace the G3's drive with a bigger faster ATA drive and use the old one as an internal backup drive and install either the 1 Gig or the 4.3 Gig mechanism in the fx?Dunno anything about the limits of drive (partition) sizes, that'd be an OS kinda thing that I've never really needed to look into, but lots of folks seem to be asking stuff like that around here lately. . . . the IIfx LIVES! YAY! jt
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Dec 2002 : 13:04:53
quote:
Why not replace the G3's drive with a bigger faster ATA drive and use the old one as an internal backup drive and install either the 1 Gig or the 4.3 Gig mechanism in the fx?
Not a bad idea. But my blue G3 is a revision A, which does not take kindly to master/slave ATA drives (the recommendation is to get an ATA card). Also, the Ultimate Plan is to use the new (well, refurb) TiBook as my main desktop machine, in which case the G3/12GB can do double duty as wife's Internet machine and backup unit. However, even Ultimate Plans are subject to revision. . . Actually (gosh, the old brain works slowly these days!), I still could take the 1G or the 4.3G out of the Q enclosures and stick one in the IIfx. But then, it shouldn't cost much to pick up a one or two G drive, either, from eBay or somewhere. . . . Then, too--I'm supposed to be working (don't tell my wife!). But yes, the IIfx lives! The fastest Mac made in 1990! /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
Kami
Junior Member
Canada
132 Posts |
Posted - 16 Dec 2002 : 20:46:28
Way to go, MrLynn. My fx is up and running - no damage from the cable problem.My IIfx has a 1 gig and a 750 MB drive installed on the platform. I changed the SCSI cable to a 2 headed one so that I had 2 drives available. The platform and the hard drive tray has brass stand offs to mount the drives on. All of the IIfx's that I have seen have had the single hard drive (160 or 250 MB) installed and look slightly different than my drive tray. Kami
|
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 16 Dec 2002 : 22:40:19
My drive looks slightly different too! http://homepage.mac.com/jwt1863/.Pictures/HACKS/IIfxIntCD/IIfxIntCDunder.jpg jt
|
foetoid
Full Member
USA
554 Posts |
Posted - 17 Dec 2002 : 05:59:14
LMAO!!!! that's too hillarious, but it's ok.... my Quadra 700 has been looking like that on and off for the past few weeks.________________ foetoid, that's (fee-toy-duh) http://www.foetoid.doesntexist.com |
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 17 Dec 2002 : 07:19:28
jt, is that the HD underneath the tray? I'd have trouble doing that, as those 16MB modules I got from Cinemafia are humongous! Where did you put the floppy drive?I've got an Apple CD 300 external (the one with the cassette) that still works, so no need to build in a CD drive. /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 17 Dec 2002 : 12:30:22
quote:
jt, is that the HD underneath the tray? I'd have trouble doing that, as those 16MB modules I got from Cinemafia are humongous! Where did you put the floppy drive?
They're still in there, one may come out for a ZIP drive, but I haven't decided . . . I have a pair of the boat-anchor external CDs for troubleshooting, but an internal for the fx seemed like the thing to do! Internal CD-ROM in IIfx Hack?jt
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 13 Jan 2003 : 21:43:26
Update:Cinemafia was kind enough to sell me a 1.2G hard drive, which arrived last week. The drive works. But not in the IIfx. Doesn't even spin up. I checked the drive in our IIci that hasn't been touched in four years--and it started right up! (what a great machine!) So assuming the cables are OK, and I believe they are, it looks to me as if the SCSI port on the IIfx motherboard is bad. Am I right? And if so, is there any solution short of replacing the board? /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
Kami
Junior Member
Canada
132 Posts |
Posted - 13 Jan 2003 : 22:43:02
You can always use a Nubus SCSI card, assuming of course that the motherboard is OK. I put a Nuport III card in my IIci just for the fun of it and it works great (you have to love those IIci's - they just work!)Kami
|
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 13 Jan 2003 : 22:55:38
Have you tested the voltages on the HDD Power cable and the mobo connector? The drive should spin up as long as it is getting power, whether the mobo is alive or the entire thing is as dead as a doornail! jt
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 14 Jan 2003 : 05:49:50
quote: Have you tested the voltages on the HDD Power cable and the mobo connector? The drive should spin up as long as it is getting power, whether the mobo is alive or the entire thing is as dead as a doornail!
I wondered about that, though the power cable is just four wires and looks pretty sturdy. I'm not sure how to go about testing the voltages, but I can swap the cable from the IIci and see if that works. /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
dunbar
New Member
USA
87 Posts |
Posted - 15 Jan 2003 : 12:56:38
Power connected, no data cable connected anywhere should get the hard disk to spin up, unless it is any of a dozen models of IBM SCSI drives with a certain jumper configuration; those will delay spin up until SCSI commands tell it to spin. Don't know about Seagates/Apples/Quantums.When I fried my Q605s SCSI, I got the flashing ? floppy, but I knew what had transpired to cause it. Conversely, a healthy logic board with nothing connected to any SCSI port and nothing in any floppy drive should always give the flashing ? floppy. Sometimes, and IIRC this is kinda rare, the logic board has 2 separate SCSI channels via 2 separate SCSI chips (I believe my (blasphemous)7500 does this). That mobo could STILL get locked up by a busy signal (sent to the CPU by a fried SCSI chip) that never goes away.... because the chip is cooked. http://www.xs4all.nl/~ganswijk/chipdir/f/scsi.htm can lead you to some chips which can repair the logic boards. Mac+=4, MacSE=1, MacSE30=1, P400=1, PB520c=1, LCI=-1, LCII=-1, Q605=1, Q650=1, UberQ950=1, PM7500=SQRT(-1). |
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 15 Jan 2003 : 22:17:38
quote:
Power connected, no data cable connected anywhere should get the hard disk to spin up, unless it is any of a dozen models of IBM SCSI drives with a certain jumper configuration; those will delay spin up until SCSI commands tell it to spin. Don't know about Seagates/Apples/Quantums.
Swapped power cable from IIci, and tried a new ribbon cable I had around: no spin. Tried power cable alone, no data cable: no spin. Drive is a Quantum. Otherwise, mobo is fine: runs from an external drive with no problem. I appreciate the link to the chip source, but I am not competent to place IC chips on logic boards. No experience, and I'm not good with itty-bitty, finicky stuff, either. I can manage to replace drives and memory sticks, but soldering teeny little wires is beyond me, even if I knew one chip from another. /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 15 Jan 2003 : 22:46:23
quote:
Otherwise, mobo is fine: runs from an external drive with no problem.
There is only the one bus, AFAIK! If it will run on an external drive, the SCSI controller MUST be fine in that case!You must not be getting power to the internal drive power socket, is there a fuse somewhere on the mobo or inside the PSU to limit the current to the internal drives? maybe test the new drive in the external case? Have you got the service manual? http://home.earthlink.net/~gamba2/manuals.html jt
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 06:54:43
quote:
You must not be getting power to the internal drive power socket, is there a fuse somewhere on the mobo or inside the PSU to limit the current to the internal drives? maybe test the new drive in the external case?
jt, the new drive works in the IIci, so it's OK. Thanks for the service-manual link. The manual is not very detailed, though. 'Servicing' seems to consist entirely of replacing major components. I don't see any reference to a fuse nor anything that looks like a fuse on the logic board. It's puzzling. . . There is a reference to a 'SCSI filter' which goes between the data cable and the internal SCSI drive, 'for third-party drives and Apple internal hard drives that shpped before March 19, 1990'. This filter is not on the original drive, and cinemo's drive is much later. /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven Edited by - mrlynn on 16 Jan 2003 07:08:16 |
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 07:33:37
quote:
Otherwise, mobo is fine: runs from an external drive with no problem.
This statement got me confused, you are not saying the IIfx will run from an external drive? I had a filter on one of my fx boxen, but I put it somewhere for safe keeping . . . . :rolleyes: jt
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 13:12:40
Yes, the IIfx runs from an external drive. But a drive plugged into the mobo doesn't work.I tested the drive from cinemafia in the IIci. It works. So the drive is not the problem. I thought you were suggesting testing it in the external enclosure. Doesn't seem necessary, since it works in the IIci. I doubt if the filter would help; as I read the manual description (which admittedly is ambiguous), it's only necessary for drives made before 1990. /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
G4from128k
Full Member
USA
873 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 15:13:28
This may not solve your problems, but the following article details one fellow's travails with his IIfx:http://www.lowendmac.com/macinschool/2k0410.html IIRC, the IIfx has a single SCSI controller. The fact that it boots with an external SCSI disks suggests that the SCSI chip is OK. The fact that nothing works when any drive is plugged in to the internal SCSI connection suggests that something bad has happened there. To me, the no-boot, no-sound, no-spin, no-pointer condition suggests a power problem. So, another interesting possibility is that the PSU is overloaded. If you go back to a low RAM config, does it boot from the old Seagate HD? Maybe the PSU can't handle all of the RAM and an internal HD, but can boot off an external HD because that HD has its own power supply. Best wishes on for a fixed fx, G4From128k by Day: Mild-Mannered Engineer and Trapeze(tm) Artist by Night: Colonel of Truth, Justice, and the Macintosh Way Reserve Officer in 68kMLA Cantankerous Coot Contingent & User of the Hockey Puck Mouse of Radial Symmetry |
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 17:34:17
quote:
To me, the no-boot, no-sound, no-spin, no-pointer condition suggests a power problem. So, another interesting possibility is that the PSU is overloaded. If you go back to a low RAM config, does it boot from the old Seagate HD? Maybe the PSU can't handle all of the RAM and an internal HD, but can boot off an external HD because that HD has its own power supply.
Nice call, sounds like a good theory and testing strategy to me!jt
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 18:43:09
Interesting (if depressing) hypothesis, but easily tested.I pulled out the humongous 16MB RAM modules, left in the four recently-acquired 4MB RAM sticks, plugged in the old drive, and started. No drive. Checked with Silverlining to make sure it wasn't secretly running: nope. Removed old drive and plugged in new one: no drive. Checked again. Conclusion: the 16MB modules are not the culprit. They do make the IIfx slow to present a bright screen on bootup, but they do not, it would seem, draw so much current that the machine can't run the internal SCSI drive. The fuse hypothesis still sounds plausible to me. Does anyone know if the IIfx has the SCSI power fused, and if so, is the fuse on the motherboard or in the power supply? And if one or the other, where? The mystery continues. . . . /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
G4from128k
Full Member
USA
873 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 19:37:29
SIGH! I'm not sure whether to be happy or sad that I was wrong.....I wonder if a bad solder joint or crack in the board is cause. Who knows what might happen if only 3 out of the 4 power pins where carrying power. This has a article mentioning SCSI fuses: http://www.nehaia.dk/cm_archives/1997/07/970704.html Any chance that those new 4 MB SIMMs are the culprit? I don't see how, but... Anyhoo, I've reached my wits end (it was a short trip) I do hope you find a fix for the problem. G4From128k
by Day: Mild-Mannered Engineer and Trapeze(tm) Artist by Night: Colonel of Truth, Justice, and the Macintosh Way Reserve Officer in 68kMLA Cantankerous Coot Contingent & User of the Hockey Puck Mouse of Radial Symmetry |
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 21:02:40
I think it is now well past the time for you to get yourself a multimeter at crap shack and spend some quality time with the instruction booklet!jt
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 21:04:40
Well, I do have a multimeter, so theoretically I could measure the voltage in the four-wire cable to the HD. . .IF I knew how. That would tell us whether the drive is getting power. Can anyone issue some instructions? /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 21:09:20
quote:
I think it is now well past the time for you to get yourself a multimeter at crap shack and spend some quality time with the instruction booklet!
Great minds think alike! I was waiting for my post to appear, when there was yours! As I said, I have the multimeter--but number one son lost the instruction booklet a few years ago. Do you know anything about those four wires? /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
alcoa
Full Member
Albania
543 Posts |
Posted - 16 Jan 2003 : 21:44:40
quote:
As I said, I have the multimeter--but number one son lost the instruction booklet a few years ago. Do you know anything about those four wires?
Check out hardwarebook.com (?) for pinouts, links on the site and in the peripherals links project here, IIRC.I always need to pull out the book I got from radio shack about "using the multi . . ." AND the freakin' instruction booklet every time I want to use mine. (VERY rarely) I'll bet there's a good multimeter howto online somewhere, google for it and add it to the LinksProj so I can find it next time! jt
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 30 Jan 2003 : 12:06:31
FYI--There are four wires in the power cable to the internal HD. The two black ones are grounds. The yellow (or orange) should be 12 volts; the red should be 5 volts (thanks to S. Pupp over on the DealMac Forum for that; he also suggested resetting the motherboard by removing the PRAM batteries and disconnecting the power supply). Report to date: Resetting the motherboard didn't help. The internal HD power supply is active. The cables are fine. Unlikely as it seems, a good HD plugged in to a good power supply in the IIfx does not spin up. But, as I said before, the external SCSI drive works fine. Is it possible that a problem with the internal SCSI data port could prevent a drive from spinning up, and not affect the external SCSI port? Could they have separate controllers? I'm out of my depth here. But it would appear that the only solutions are either a replacement motherboard, or a NuBus SCSI card--or just to run the IIfx from the external. All perfectly viable options, but still, it would be nice to know exactly what the problem is. ]:-( /Mr Lynn The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |
dunbar
New Member
USA
87 Posts |
Posted - 11 Feb 2003 : 13:07:18
Termination resistors? Nobody is talking about terminations. Internal drive = No terminations on the SCSI drive (IIRC, mobo has terminator). External drive = Last device on bus is terminated, middle SCSI stuff is not terminated.Ram: Lotsa ram = looooong time to boot - my Q950 demonstrated that to me. DRIVEs power connection (visit http://www.seagate.com/support/disc/specs/scsi/st251n.html) PS: Sorry for the delay, I'm a Luzr. Mac+=4, MacSE=1, MacSE30=1, P400=1, PB520c=1, LCI=-1, LCII=-1, Q605=1, Q650=1, UberQ950=1, PM7500=SQRT(-1). |
clancychem
Starting Member
USA
18 Posts |
Posted - 11 Feb 2003 : 14:36:25
I've had some trouble with some SCSI hard drives in several of my Macs as well. I've screwed several up by accidentally bending a pin on the SCSI connector or stopping a hard drive format by restarting the computer. In each case, the hard drives became unreadable with any Mac I put them in. I couldn't find any utility that could read the drives.To try to salvage the drives, I put them in an old 486 (on separate occasions) that had a bootable SCSI controller. I low-level formatted one of them and did a regular format on the other. In both cases, they held the format under DOS and Windows. Afterwards I was able to format them on a Mac. They were usable and bootable. I hope this is helpful to anyone with similar problems. Clancychem
|
MrLynn
Junior Member
USA
394 Posts |
Posted - 16 Feb 2003 : 08:07:08
More on the slow-running saga of the IIfx hard drive problem:Finally got around to testing the original IIfx drive in the IIci: works fine! So there is something wrong that prevents that drive from working in the IIfx. Same goes for the 1G that I also tried. Since the drive is getting power, I assume it must be the motherboard. But shouldn't the drive spin up if it's getting power, EVEN IF the mobo can't see it? A corresondent over on DealMac suggests that maybe the power supply is adequate to run the drive but not to start it up. Does that sound likely to anyone here? Testing would require more sophistication (and time) than I have. Well, Cinemo is sending me his IIfx chassis (with mobo and PSU), so that'll give me some part-swapping capability. Course I'll have to watch out for the SAF as I bring another old Mac into the house . . . /Mr Lynn PS Dunbar: The IIfx requires a special (black) terminator at the end of any external SCSI chain. It also requires a terminator between the ribbon cable and the internal hard drive IF the drive is not internally terminated, which as far as I can determine means made before 1990. My 160MB original drive has no such terminator, and never needed one. The dinosaurs became extinct because they didn’t have a space program. --Larry Niven |