Well I iopened up the drive and the platter was stuck pretty well. I don’t think it had to do with the heads, it was the spindle just gummed up. I freed it up which took some moving back and forth. I could feel a high friction spot in the rotation. I got it spinning and ran it a couple hours. Now it spins freely and starts every time.
The heads are another thing entirely. They always move and never appear stuck. They sometimes wander randomly in an oscillation pattern. Sometimes they work fine, You can tell when you power it on how it is going to be.
I did get the computer to boot off the drive twice and it worked perfectly. Once it works, it works great! The drive was last accessed in 1999. It has some fun sounds for startup, shutdown, etc. as well as a cool after dark screensaver and Word, Excel, and Quicken.
I’m not sure if this is the “goo” problem since the heads always move and the drive never spins down. I think for some reason on most power ups the drive loses the ability to control head position. I may try to image the drive just in case there is something good on it.