68k Macintosh Liberation Army Forums
68k Macintosh Liberation Army Forums
Home | Members | Search | FAQ
 All Forums
 Lounge
 Recomendations for Replacement
Author Topic  
Fedorenko
Junior Member


Australia
463 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  03:21:35
Im currently looking into a possible replacemnt for the Powerbook 180c, that as you may know, is now operating in a reduced capacity, and may slip closer to death at anytime.

Thankful, the PAF barrier has been broken, so now Im on the search for a new computer. I have come up with a short list of computer that I am intereasted in:

-Power Macintosh 9600 MP
-Power Macintosh 9500
-Power Macintosh 9500 MP
-Power Macintosh 8500
-Power Macintosh 7600
-Power Macintosh 7300
-Power Macintosh 4400
-Performa 6400
-Performa 6360

You may notice that this is, the list of compatable macs for BeOS, so no prizes for guessing one of the wanted uses for this system is. Out of that list, which systems would you sugest based on the following duties I am expecting the computer to accomplish:

-Instant messaging using MSN, ICQ, AIM and Yahoo.
-Browse the internet.
-Play games (primarily strategy)
-Use BeOS
-Turn into a TV using the Apple TV Tuner Card and remote
-Play MP3s

Another factor is that this system is going into a corner desk that I am going to get built into my room, so it needs to be neat. I would also appreciate sugestions on which MacOS to install onto the chosen system.

I am willing to spend a bit on this, and when including one of these wireless telephone extenders (http://www.innovations.com.au/cda/product/sku/0,1568,4021-11,00.html), I would be willing to spend around 500 Australian dollars.

Thanks for your help.

Good ideas usually are created by crazy people, go figure...

q950
Junior Member


USA
135 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  08:07:17
I have a 6400 with a tuner card that i never use anymore, I might sell it. Contact me through email if you are interested in it.

Logan

Quadra 950, Workgroup Server 9150, Performa 6400, Powerbook 2300c, 4x Quadra 700's, iBookGo to Top of Page

G4from128k
Full Member


USA
873 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  08:17:13
I like the compact form factor of the 7300 & 7600 -- they make a great monitor stands. They have 8 RAM slots, 3 PCI slots, room for 2 HDs, and are really easy to open'n'upgrade. Their dual SCSI bus design is nice because it means you can have up to 14 SCSI devices. If you don't need built-in video input, then the 7300 is good enough.

On the other hand, the larger tower of the 8500 is great for its built-in AV I/O features. For example, you can use a regular TV as a monitor (either mirrored or as a second monitor if you have 4 MB VRAM). The 8500 is roomier inside for larger HDs, but adding RAM, VRAM, or cache is a major PITA.

And if a huge machine is no trouble and expansion is top-priority, then the 9600 is the way to go. The MP feature might be cool for some applications (will BeOS us MP in these Macs?), but you could not run OS X on an MP machine. I'd would avoid the 4400, 6400, or 6360 because they have lower performance, limited expandability (only 2 or 3 ram slots), and can't run OS X AFAIK. The only good thing about those machines is that they use IDE drives (drives are cheaper and bigger vs. SCSI).

As of OS, I like 8.6 on my 7300, 7500, and 9500. IMO, 8.6 has great features, good stability, good performance, and is is not a big resource hog like 9 is.

G4From128k

by Day: Mild-Mannered Engineer and Trapeze(tm) Artist
by Night: Colonel of Truth, Justice, and the Macintosh Way
Reserve Officer in 68kMLA Cantankerous Coot Contingent
Go to Top of Page

Unknown_K
Full Member


USA
602 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  09:23:42
It depends what you want to run on the unit.

Your notebook is a 68030-33, so a step up to a Q840av would run your old software faster , cost very little, and uses standard 72pin simms so upgrading all the way to 128mb is cheap. It can hold 2 hd's and has superb A/V capture both for sound and video. I have one of these machines and its nice.

If you want a PPC unit I would recommend a 7500 desktop where everything is easy to get to. I have both the 7500 and 8500. the major difference is while both let you capture video using RCA and SVHS input the 8500 has video out while the 7500 doesnt. Upgrading the memory is alot easier in a 7500 then 8500 (same memory just harder to get to.) Also the 7500 is a desktop while the 8500 is a tower so you need more space with the 8500 (monitor fits on top of 7500 easily). I have a g3-400 in the 8500 and its fast for its age. Both machines have ATA/66 IDE cards so storage is fast and cheap on both units. If you do buy the 7500 get an faster processor then the stock 603/100. I put my 604/120 from the 8500 into my 7500 and someday will probably get a g3 which are about $100 or so new these days. If you like more PCI slots and dont care about built in Audio/Video capture then go with the 9500 (same design as the 8500 but streched case, 4 more memory slots and 3 more PCI slots 1 used for video card).

Go to Top of Page

oldmacman
Full Member


USA
713 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  09:55:12
I wouldn't go with the 6400 unless you get a PCI card for video. The onboard video isn't too quick.

Official 68kMLA Music and NeXT Expert
Macs Liberated: SE (2), LC, IIsi, PB 145b, Quadra 700 (2), LC 575, 6100 (2), PB 5300, PowerMac 5400/200, Performa 6400/180
PCs liberated from Windoze: 3Go to Top of Page

Da Penguin
Senior Member


USA
1094 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  11:52:04
The 9600 MP

BeOS wil FLY!!!!

Or you could throw a MP card into a 7600, hehe.

~The Penguin

**| Want free 68kmla email? Drop me a line |**
| Captain, Intelligence Operations / Space Cowboy |
| "The choice has been made, but now you must understand it" |Go to Top of Page

~tl
Junior Member


United Kingdom
312 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  12:08:21
yeah if you can find a 9500MP or a 9600MP it will rock for BeOS

Orcadian MLA Division
68ks Liberated: 2Go to Top of Page

Gothikon
Full Member


Australia
537 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  14:49:17
I'd reduce that list to

-Power Macintosh 9500
-Power Macintosh 8500
-Power Macintosh 7600
-Power Macintosh 7300

Stay away from the 4400, the Performas aren't bad but I can't get the BeOS to work on mine, I think it's just me though.

The MP machines will probably be overpriced, if you can get one for the same price as an SP go ahead, otherwise it's not worth it.

Now that that's said and done I can make you an offer! A friend and I have 3 PowerMacs to sell an 8600, a 7300 and a PowerTower Pro 225. All include some RAM, an HD a CD a floppy, ethernet. The PowerTowerPro does not have a CPU at the moment or video card but I can probably find both. The PowerTowerPro is probably the best of those machines as it is basically a 9500 so it has 6 PCI slots, it also uses al large ATX case with 4 5.25 bays and 2 3.5 bays and a dedicated floppy bay.

All of these machines are in good condition, you might want to check the PowerTowerPro for BeOS compatibility but it is essentially a 9500 made during the clone era. You can have the PowerTowerPro for 100 AUD plus postage, + what ever the CPU and video card cost unless you get them from someone else. You could probably get them for under 50 AUD each. I think my friend is look for about 300 for the 8600 with monitor, I'll need to check on that.

email me at

adam (AT) gothikon (d o t) com

I'd be really pleased if you'd take the PTP (so would my girlfriend!!) it needs a good home and I just don't the space for it right now. I'm not sure where you are but I'm 99% certain we are both in Australia so postage would be around 20-40 AUD.

EDIT - Just noticed you were looking at spending 500 AUD! The PTP with CPU and Video would probably come in at around 200.

More detail on the specs (just had a look) Apple 8x CD ROM, 1 gig Apple Quantum HD 64MB of RAM, more available. Clean install of OS 9.0.4 Apple Extended 2 keyboard and mouse.

I just checked and the PowerTower Pro is listed as BeOS compatible.

Edited by - gothikon on 31 Aug 2003 15:14:36Go to Top of Page

cory5412
68KMLA Comrade-in-Arms


USA
4679 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  18:10:12
Go for a 6500 instead of the 6400 ;)

BeOS can't use it's SubWoofer :( but with OS9 and iTunes, it makes great for everything you had just said. and it has a TVslot...
I won't offer to sell you mine, because shippinbg woiuld be horrific from my part of the USA to Aurstrailia where you live.

I'd go with the 8600, it has the great design of the 9600, some of them can use very fast processors (350MHz or dual 200/250MHz from the MP macs IIRC) and it has audio video in and nout. I'm not sure if it had the 6 PCI slots or not, but either way still cool

Official 68k videographer
Official MLA TourGuide
Editor of the MLAgazine
"I'm just a normal computer geek who somehow landed a social life"Go to Top of Page

Fedorenko
Junior Member


Australia
463 Posts
Posted - 31 Aug 2003 :  23:45:47
The Powermac 9600 is not compatable with BeOS....only the MP version. Thanks Gothikon for the offer, but I cant take it, right now, I have the money, but I cant do it right now. Give me a week or 2 (and by all means, if you can find someone to buy it, take their offer).

Thanks for your help everybody.

Good ideas usually are created by crazy people, go figure...Go to Top of Page

maclover5
LC Doctor/Hot Rodder


Australia
5830 Posts
Posted - 01 Sep 2003 :  00:13:28
Dumb question i know, but will BeOS run on Beige G3s? I think it does, and it does everything you want it to, as well as being able to run OS X. Only one caveat: To do any AV stuff, you'll need to get your hands on a WINGS Personality card, which isn't that easy to find.

"**** em" - Jobs in regards to customers
Warrior maclover5
68kMLA

Official 68kMLA Detective
Number of 68ks Liberated: 7
Number of Contraband (PPC) Liberated from the Dumpster: 1Go to Top of Page

Fedorenko
Junior Member


Australia
463 Posts
Posted - 01 Sep 2003 :  00:45:07
It cant. G3s came after Apple decided not to buy Be, so they didnt give them information anymore about the motherboards.

I see PTPs and other Power Computing motherboards are ATX. Does taht mean I could get a nice fancy PC ATX case and put the mac in there?

Good ideas usually are created by crazy people, go figure...

Edited by - Fedorenko on 01 Sep 2003 00:46:46Go to Top of Page

cory5412
68KMLA Comrade-in-Arms


USA
4679 Posts
Posted - 01 Sep 2003 :  01:07:35
By all means yes...

and yeah, the 9600's are compatible with BeOS... otherwise the 9600MP wouldn't be compatible

Official 68k videographer
Official MLA TourGuide
Editor of the MLAgazine
"I'm just a normal computer geek who somehow landed a social life"Go to Top of Page

Fedorenko
Junior Member


Australia
463 Posts
Posted - 01 Sep 2003 :  01:35:49
They arnt....mostly.

Any 9600 over 300mhz is instantly incompatable. Most 9600s are incompatable under 300mhz as there was 2 revisions of the board. One works, one doesnt. I have spent alot of my computing intereasted life looking at BeOS, I know what Im talking about

Good ideas usually are created by crazy people, go figure...Go to Top of Page

Gothikon
Full Member


Australia
537 Posts
Posted - 01 Sep 2003 :  03:14:43
quote:

The Powermac 9600 is not compatable with BeOS

It's a clone of a 9500 and is listed as BeOS compatible in the BeOS 4 notes/BeOS bible ?? Perhaps you were replying to someone elses comment regarding that...

quote:

....only the MP version.

I would be extremely surprised if BeOS will run on a 9600 MP but not an SP, I am not surprised that it won't run on the Mach 5 models (250MHz and above)

quote:

Thanks Gothikon for the offer, but I cant take it, right now, I have the money, but I cant do it right now. Give me a week or 2

This machine really isn't going anywhere in a hurry, if you don't buy it it's going to sit in the cupboard indefinitely, although I'm tempted to do some generic mods on it, quieter fans, case window, top window, braided cables etc...

I'll even trade for some PC 100 RAM or any airport related equipment.

If you decide you want another machine as I said a friend has a 7300 and an 8600 ready to go with a 200MHz chip in each.

Anyway, if you want it in 2 weeks let me know.

--------
LC 2, LC 3, Q605, Perf 638, Colour Classic (160 603e) 6100, 7200, PTP 225 (Quad 604), PM 9600, G4 CubeGo to Top of Page

Fedorenko
Junior Member


Australia
463 Posts
Posted - 01 Sep 2003 :  15:42:29
Yeh, I know its odd about the 9600 buisness, but remember the time they were being produced, Apple had decided not to buy Be Inc, so all of the information regarding the motherboards were no longer making it to Be. This caused them to jump over to the intel side of things.

Good ideas usually are created by crazy people, go figure...Go to Top of Page

cory5412
68KMLA Comrade-in-Arms


USA
4679 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  06:24:46
the Power Macintosh 9600 falls under one of three catagories of machine in your original list.

Catagory1) PowerSurge:
7300,7600, 9500, 8500, 9600 and 8600 (as I recall)
BeOS is compatible with all of these machines.
Catagory2)Gazelle (was this the name?)
6360, 6400, 6500, TAM
Catagory3)"some other dealie"
4400

the 4400 is least likely to be compatible with the BeOS, I hear that there's a "Mach5" revision of the 9600 and 8600, but why would the Mach4 8600 be compatible with BeOS, and the 9600SP not? 8600s are all SP IIRC only difference is three slots and the video subsystems...

I'm not sure if the 9600 and 8600 are different from the PowerSurge machines, and people I'm talking to don't even seem to know what I'm talking about on the whole "PowerSurge" machine... I'll get back to this on that, because I saw it on the XPostFacto website.

Official 68k videographer
Official MLA TourGuide
Editor of the MLAgazine
"I'm just a normal computer geek who somehow landed a social life"Go to Top of Page

Alien
Junior Member


Netherlands
269 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  09:57:39
I'd go for an 8500, and then try to find a 9500's MP card for it. The major difference between the 8500 and the 9500 is the three extra slots in the latter, but you won't fill those under BeOS; there aren't enough supported PCI cards.

The ultimate BeOS machine is the Daystar Genesis quad-processor monster, BTW. Good luck finding one!

,xtG
.tsooJ

--
who | grep -i blonde | date
cd ~; unzip; touch; strip; finger
mount; gasp; yes; uptime; umount
sleepGo to Top of Page

cory5412
68KMLA Comrade-in-Arms


USA
4679 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  10:42:30
This is a stretch here, but on EveryMac.com, we see the "MaxxBoxx" (Metrowerks computers or something like that)

It's a German-Made monster, sporting 4-16 200MHz 604e processors, (as I recall anyway) and up to 1.5GB of RAM..

that'd probably be best with a BSD or Yellow Dog Linux or something.

Official 68k videographer
Official MLA TourGuide
Editor of the MLAgazine
"I'm just a normal computer geek who somehow landed a social life"Go to Top of Page

Unknown_K
Full Member


USA
602 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  11:24:19
If you want to run BEOS or a version of Linux get a cheap intel box

Go to Top of Page

cory5412
68KMLA Comrade-in-Arms


USA
4679 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  19:25:45
Yeah, BeOS 5PE has been rereleased by a new developer, only for intel, to work on some fantastic new hardware, so you can basically buy any brand new PC, or build one, and BeOS will work. I'm not sure if it's a BeOS6 or what...

any linux runs on anything, mostly

other than that, get an 8600/300 and run OS9.0 on it.

Official 68k videographer
Official MLA TourGuide
Editor of the MLAgazine
"I'm just a normal computer geek who somehow landed a social life"Go to Top of Page

Da Penguin
Senior Member


USA
1094 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  19:47:25
Doesnt someone in the MLA have a quad 604 card?

Man, I want one of those for my 7600 *drools*

~The Penguin

**| Want free 68kmla email? Drop me a line |**
| Captain, Intelligence Operations / Space Cowboy |
| "The choice has been made, but now you must understand it" |Go to Top of Page

Unknown_K
Full Member


USA
602 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  20:43:25
quote:

Doesnt someone in the MLA have a quad 604 card?

Man, I want one of those for my 7600 *drools*

~The Penguin

**| Want free 68kmla email? Drop me a line |**
| Captain, Intelligence Operations / Space Cowboy |
| "The choice has been made, but now you must understand it" |


Wow a quad card that no OS or software for the mac can ever use. Might as well tape 2 extra 604 processors on the side of the case.


Go to Top of Page

Fedorenko
Junior Member


Australia
463 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  21:04:34
quote:

the 4400 is least likely to be compatible with the BeOS, I hear that there's a "Mach5" revision of the 9600 and 8600, but why would the Mach4 8600 be compatible with BeOS, and the 9600SP not? 8600s are all SP IIRC only difference is three slots and the video subsystems...

Look, that list in my first post is the official BeOS compat list. Therefore, its right.

If I wanted a simple BeOS/Linux install, I would get an intel box. I have considered all options quite carefully, thankyou very much.

Sorry if ive been snapy...Im at school, and im tired

Good ideas usually are created by crazy people, go figure...Go to Top of Page

cory5412
68KMLA Comrade-in-Arms


USA
4679 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  22:07:47
When I said Mach4 8600, I meant Mach5... (just so you know)

the 8600 and 9600 were always released and sold in parallel, so I don't know why it wouldnt work on the 9600.

If you know about BeOS, then you know that for intel, it supports MUCH newer hardware now,and you know that just about ALL the programs for BeOS in ANY form, are available just about ONLY for X86...

that's enough to convince me....

Yes, there is support for quad processors.

Linux and Unix, (not OSX/rhap though) support it, BeOS will support it IIRC, and there are photothop and other programs and plugins for things to support it.

the MaxxBoxx thingy was only from Germany though...

Official 68k videographer
Official MLA TourGuide
Editor of the MLAgazine
"I'm just a normal computer geek who somehow landed a social life"Go to Top of Page

Fedorenko
Junior Member


Australia
463 Posts
Posted - 02 Sep 2003 :  22:45:48
The 8600 is not supported either.

I know very well that BeOS software, is both mostly avaiable for x86 and modern hardware is avaiable for it, I just wanted to do something DIFFERENT!

Good ideas usually are created by crazy people, go figure...Go to Top of Page

Da Penguin
Senior Member


USA
1094 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  05:15:22
IIRC there were also some (not very well) written drivers/extensions for the card.

I did mention the quad cpu under the thought of BeOS though, that sucker would be awesome!

~The Penguin

**| Want free 68kmla email? Drop me a line |**
| Captain, Intelligence Operations / Space Cowboy |
| "The choice has been made, but now you must understand it" |Go to Top of Page

cory5412
68KMLA Comrade-in-Arms


USA
4679 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  05:40:15
BeOS at all is different, I mean... well for one commercial development has been discontinued. Then there's the whole "ubercommunity" following it, have you READ some of the stuff about when Be, INC was still active? they had, and probably still do have a pretty well off following.
The Intel version is still being developed on, and developed for, opensourcelike... Maybe you could start something like this for the PowerPC version...

so basically, your ONLY option is a 7300, 850, 9500. Your original list had 8600 by the way.

What version of BeOS do you have anyway? I believe that the version I have is R5 (intel) R5PE (intel) and R4.1/5 (PowerPC)


If I were you, I'd go with the 7300, I've never tested the video I/O functions of the other macs with BeOS, but then again, I'd also get an 8600/300 and use it as an AV mac, or a 6500/whatever and use it as a jukebox (subwoofer=good)

A 9600/300 (didn't they make a 9600/350 as well?) would make a fantastic OSX machine, maybe you could get a 9600/200MP and work on getting multiple processors to work in OSX... (it'd be uber.)

Official 68k videographer
Official MLA TourGuide
Editor of the MLAgazine
"I'm just a normal computer geek who somehow landed a social life"Go to Top of Page

Alien
Junior Member


Netherlands
269 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  07:32:56
quote:
the MaxxBoxx thingy was only from Germany though...

Not to mention rarer than tits on a fish, if not completely vapourware...

,xtG
.tsooJ

--
who | grep -i blonde | date
cd ~; unzip; touch; strip; finger
mount; gasp; yes; uptime; umount
sleepGo to Top of Page

Unknown_K
Full Member


USA
602 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  08:15:14
Did any of the clones make a machine that wasnt just a mac motherboard in a different case? It looks like they just took the mac designs without doing much engineering at all (designing cases dont count)

Go to Top of Page

Alien
Junior Member


Netherlands
269 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  09:12:39
That was pretty much the deal. Although Apple (and through Apple other clone manufacturers) actually licensed some of the technology used in the Tsunami multiprocessing machines from Daystar.

There was some R&D going on, but mostly it came down on Apple, who became unprofitable because of this. That is part of the reason why the clones had to go.

,xtG
.tsooJ

--
who | grep -i blonde | date
cd ~; unzip; touch; strip; finger
mount; gasp; yes; uptime; umount
sleepGo to Top of Page

q950
Junior Member


USA
135 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  12:52:42
I know radius was doing some cool stuff. While I was looking for parts for my telecase I came across a piece for a certain Radius computer. It was a riser card that had 2 PCI and 2 Nubus slots on it. That would have been one cool computer, using my telecast in it and being able to put some badass graphics and scsi cards in it.

Logan

Quadra 950, Workgroup Server 9150, Performa 6400, Powerbook 2300c, 4x Quadra 700's, iBookGo to Top of Page

Gothikon
Full Member


Australia
537 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  14:31:05
quote:

Did any of the clones make a machine that wasnt just a mac motherboard in a different case? It looks like they just took the mac designs without doing much engineering at all (designing cases dont count)

The Power Tower Pro I have sitting here is like a 9500 but the board is not the same as it's in an ATX case, I beleive the chips, functions of the board are the same but the layout is different.

And as someone else said I also remember a few Radius clones, I think they had a name simillar to the 8100 and they had nubus and PCI slots.

I would be interested to know what performance was like though when it was using both types of card.

--------
LC 2, LC 3, Q605, Perf 638, Colour Classic (160 603e) 6100, 7200, PTP 225 (Quad 604), PM 9600, G4 CubeGo to Top of Page

Trash80toG-4
NIGHT STALKER


USA
2899 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  17:04:05
quote:

quote:

Did any of the clones make a machine that wasnt just a mac motherboard in a different case? It looks like they just took the mac designs without doing much engineering at all (designing cases dont count)


And as someone else said I also remember a few Radius clones, I think they had a name simillar to the 8100 and they had nubus and PCI slots.

I would be interested to know what performance was like though when it was using both types of card.



The Radius 81/110 only has NuBus, the only difference from the stock 8100 mobo is that it has the standard DB-15 connector.

The first couple of generations of clones were just repackaged mobos with some minor variations. The NuBus/PCI riser card was made for one of the later generation Power Computing mobos. I've got good piccies of it somewhere from an eBay auction.

jt .
Trash Hauler: call sign: eight-ball
C.O. AC-130H SpecOps 68kMLAAFGo to Top of Page

cory5412
68KMLA Comrade-in-Arms


USA
4679 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  19:39:06
I thought that the clone mobos weren't apple mobos in a different case (apple could do that!) but rather, machines lightly based on apple-made architechtures, but designed and made by the clone makers

PowerComputing, UMAX, Radius and (*maybe) Moto basically had the only unique designs, most others were literally direct copies of either PowerComputing or moto.

Official 68k videographer
Official MLA TourGuide
Editor of the MLAgazine
"I'm just a normal computer geek who somehow landed a social life"Go to Top of Page

Fedorenko
Junior Member


Australia
463 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  22:58:33
-Power Macintosh 9600 MP
-Power Macintosh 9500
-Power Macintosh 9500 MP
-Power Macintosh 8500
-Power Macintosh 7600
-Power Macintosh 7300
-Power Macintosh 4400
-Performa 6400
-Performa 6360

I dont see 8600 on there, and I havent edited my first post..

OpenBeOS is most likely going to be a PPC Peegaus based system. Yellowtab, however, si the primary x86 developer, and will succeed, unlike OBOS, IMHO.

Good ideas usually are created by crazy people, go figure...Go to Top of Page

Unknown_K
Full Member


USA
602 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  22:59:04
I always found the clone thing to be stupid. The reason clones worked on the PC side is because the companies only had to clone the BIOS the rest of the parts were open source fully documented and off the shelf. Once you make your own bios you can do all the design work cheaply without relying on information from IBM. Apple clones relied on apple doing all the design work so the clone makers were tied to them directly. The platform was still proprietary so no new companies would build anything usefull. All the clone makers did was cheapen the product and cut margins (which was easy with no r&d needed) and watch apple choke on lower margins and alot of R&d work.

Go to Top of Page

Trash80toG-4
NIGHT STALKER


USA
2899 Posts
Posted - 03 Sep 2003 :  23:39:18
quote:

All the clone makers did was cheapen the product and cut margins (which was easy with no r&d needed) and watch apple choke on lower margins and alot of R&d work.


That's not really the case, the clone makers were innovating at a rate which Apple chose not to match. Apple's "engineering certification" process ended up an excuse/means to hold the cloners back. Even the Apple apologists at MacWorld magazine were forced to take notice when not a single Apple product was the top performer in any category once the clone makers got rolling.

Using industry standard case designs that included open bays and PSU's with the power/cooling budget to spare for using them can hardly be considered "cheapening" the product. That was the CHRP roadmap Apple had agreed to pursue and pulling the rug out from under their partner Motorola along with the rest of the clones was probably one of the main reasons for the performance gap of the PPC vs. Intel/AMD CPUs when Moto shifted effort to the embedded processor market.

jt .
Trash Hauler: call sign: eight-ball
C.O. AC-130H SpecOps 68kMLAAFGo to Top of Page

Gothikon
Full Member


Australia
537 Posts
Posted - 04 Sep 2003 :  03:52:24
quote:

Doesnt someone in the MLA have a quad 604 card?

Man, I want one of those for my 7600 *drools*


I have a Quad 132 card made by daystar, it's a beast of a card and has some weird debuggin ports or something on it. I also have a boxed mint retail copy of BeOS 4.5 and the BeOS bible.
What I don't have is a BeOS compatible graphics card, I sold all my mac PCI vid cards about a year ago before I got the BeOS, all I have now is a non compatible V5500 64!

BeOS is about the only thing that will take advantage of this card.

One day it will be my uber BeOS server, probably an MP3 player.

What the BeOS really needs is a decent web browser, if it had that it would be a whole lot more useful.

And I'm not convinced that any of the BeOS variants are really going anywhere most seem to be turning in to linux like bloatware with installation CDs full of useless guff and few real imporvements.

--------
LC 2, LC 3, Q605, Perf 638, Colour Classic (160 603e) 6100, 7200, PTP 225 (Quad 604), PM 9600, G4 CubeGo to Top of Page

cory5412
68KMLA Comrade-in-Arms


USA
4679 Posts
Posted - 04 Sep 2003 :  05:21:40
Fedorenko:
If you know exactly what machine you wanted, you shoudln't have asked us. Plain and simple, I'm almost certain that there's people here who have used BeOS, or who plan to like Gothikon.
I'm included in those people, and certainly would wonder why the 8600, AND the 9600 are both unsupported, but the 7300 IS supported. These three machines, are the three machines of nearly exact same era, speedinesses and such, but the desktops never made it to Mach5-ness.

If you really want to be unique, become a BeOS developer, make "OpenBeOS" (which is NOT! what I was talking about....) work on the 8600/9600.

If you want to be unique, get a BeBOX... it's got dual 603e or ev (forgot which) processors running at about 160/180 MHz, IIRC, it's pretty much standard hardware in there, but with some really cool twists (well blinkenlights is one of the funnesses.

Official 68k videographer
Official MLA TourGuide
Editor of the MLAgazine
"I'm just a normal computer geek who somehow landed a social life"Go to Top of Page

Da Penguin
Senior Member


USA
1094 Posts
Posted - 04 Sep 2003 :  16:59:55
/me is off to install BeOS 5 on his 7600, I will let y'all know how it goes.

~The Penguin

**| Want free 68kmla email? Drop me a line |**
| Captain, Intelligence Operations / Space Cowboy |
| "The choice has been made, but now you must understand it" |Go to Top of Page

Topic is 2 Pages Long:
  1  2
 

68k Macintosh Liberation Army Forums

© 2001-2003 68kMLA

Go To Top Of Page

68k of the Week: kastegir's PowerBook 180.