I haven't found an IDE mSATA adapter and card that will work in my Lombard, including that Ableconn that I use successfully in my 3400, Pismo, iBook G4 and Mac mini G4. There has got to be something about the IDE controllers used in the generation of machines between the 3400 and the Pismo. Something modern IDE adapters don't implement that drives of that era did.
I/O and disk controllers:
2400/3400: O'Hare
Wallstreet: Heathrow - Problematic
Lombard: Paddington - Problematic
Pismo: KeyLargo
Need to look at the desktops I have and see if the ones with the same controllers have the same problem...
So I need to make a correction, the
Ableconn mSata to IDE adapter does work in a Lombard! My mistake was not double checking the jumper, like many other Macs of this generation IDE hard disks need to be set to Master, which for this adapter is nothing connected/no jumpers on either 45-46 or 47-48. I had tested with an adapter I was using in a PM 7300 on a Sonnet PCI ATA adapter which was fine with the adapter as shipped (47-48 jumper = Cable Select). What confuses me a lot with this is that there doesn't seem to be a standard on these jumpers, on some drives 47-48 being jumped does mean Master! For example: that new
Yansen 16GB 2.5-inch PATA/IDE 44-Pin SSD I bought.
I tested with three mSATA SSDs:
All worked fine. The first two I had on hand but I recently bought the 230S card as it was mentioned in another thread (which I now can't find) as working in mSATA adapters when other mSATA SSDs would not. I was dubious on that thinking the adapter would mask the any subtle differences in mSATA SSDs...
So I decided to try these three mSATA SSDs in the two other "cheap" mSATA to IDE adapters I have with the Lombard:
These two adapters are very similar (use same JM20330 Serial ATA Bridge Chip) but have some differences in populated passive components that I had thought might change their compatibility.
As previously tested with them the 370 and 380M still did not work in either. However the 230S worked in both of them! Not sure what to make of that other than the 230S (despite the lower model number) is a newer mSATA SSD, perhaps it better supports ATA modes that the Lombard uses?
In any case the combination of a cheap green board adapter and a 64MB Transcend 230S mSATA SSD is about the same cost as the 16GB Yansen PATA/IDE 44-Pin SSD (~$36) but with 4 times the capacity.